Autumn offer (-10% on a selection) with the code: "AUTOMNE10" until 27/10 - SHIPS IN 24–48H · DELIVERY IN 2 TO 5 DAYS (items in stock)

0

5 March 2024 15 min read

14K VS 18K GOLD: WHICH IS BEST?

Whether you are buying a piece of jewelry or an engagement ring online or offline, you have probably noticed that most settings are available in two different types of gold: 14K and 18K.

18K gold consists of 18 parts pure gold mixed with 6 parts of other metals. Depending on the color of the gold (e.g., white gold, yellow gold, or rose gold), these metals can include nickel, silver, copper, zinc, and palladium. Expressed as a percentage, 18-karat gold is 75% pure gold.

14-karat gold, on the other hand, consists of 14 parts pure gold mixed with 10 parts of other metals, which also vary depending on the color of the gold. Expressed as a percentage, the pure gold in a 14-karat gold piece of jewelry represents 58.3% of the total metal.

In the United States, most engagement rings are made of 14-karat (14K) gold. However, it is also common for some engagement ring settings to be made of 18-karat gold. While these two types of gold may look similar, there are actually several major differences between them.

We explain these differences below, along with what you need to know if you are struggling to choose between 14K and 18K gold for an engagement ring, necklace, bracelet, pair of earrings, or any other piece of quality jewelry.

Looking to sell your gold? This article is designed to help those looking to purchase jewelry. If you are looking to sell your gold, please feel free to check out our Selling Your Jewelry page. If you are looking to sell your diamond engagement ring, we have a specific article on selling diamonds.

What is the difference between 14K and 18K gold?

Contrary to popular belief, the gold jewelry you buy is generally not made of pure gold. In fact, almost all gold jewelry is made from an alloy created by combining pure gold with a variety of other metals.

Karats Gold ratio Purity % Millennial fineness
18K 18/24 75 750
14K 14/24 58.3 583/585
Gold fineness is expressed in parts per 24. For example, pure gold is 24K, as all 24 out of 24 parts consist of pure gold.

The reason for this is that pure gold is very soft. If engagement rings, earrings, and other jewelry were made of pure gold, they would scratch, scuff, dent, and deform very easily, often just from brushing against another surface.

There is also the question of color: instead of the warm golden color that most of us associate with gold jewelry, pure gold is actually closer to orange in color.

This is why modern gold jewelry uses gold mixed with other metals. The purity of this gold is measured using the karat system, which provides information on the percentage of pure gold contained in any type of gold.

14k vs 18k gold

Pros and cons of 14-karat and 18-karat gold

14K and 18K gold are both commonly used for engagement rings—in fact, they are two very popular options for engagement ring settings. Both types of gold have their own pros and cons, whether in terms of appearance, cost, durability, or other aspects. We have listed them below.

Pros of 14K gold

14K gold has several advantages. First of all, it is affordable. Since pure gold makes up 58.3% of the metal content of 14K gold, a 14K gold engagement ring will generally cost a little less than the same ring in 18K gold.

Secondly, 14K gold is quite durable. Gold is a soft, malleable metal that scratches, bends, and deforms easily. This means that the purer a gold engagement ring is, the easier it is to scratch on door frames, desks, tables, floors, and other surfaces.

While 14-karat gold is not as durable as platinum or palladium, it is more than durable enough for the average person. It is also much more durable than 18-karat gold, making it the best choice if your future fiancée has an active lifestyle or works with their hands.

Thirdly, although 14-karat gold is not as pure as 18-karat gold, its relatively high pure gold content allows it to retain the warmth and rich color that people associate with gold. While it may look slightly dull compared to 18-karat gold, 14-karat gold is dazzling in its own right.

Finally, 14-karat gold is ubiquitous and widely available in the world of engagement rings. It is by far the most popular type of gold for engagement rings, accounting for about 90% of all rings sold in the United States, the UK, and other Western countries. It is therefore an easy option to find.

Cons of 14K gold

14-karat gold is popular for a very specific reason: for most people, it is the best choice. However, it does have a few minor drawbacks.

First of all, for some people, 14-karat gold is not as aesthetically pleasing as 18-karat gold. While its color is rich and impressive, the look of 14K gold is not as strong as that of 18K gold due to its lower degree of purity.

Secondly, although it is unlikely for both types of gold, 14-karat gold is slightly more likely to cause skin allergies than 18-karat gold. If your future fiancé(e) is allergic to silver, copper, nickel, zinc, or iron, this could be a point in favor of 18-karat gold.

Pros of 18K gold

The main advantage of 18-karat gold is its purity. As the purest form of gold that can be used for an engagement ring, an 18-karat gold ring offers the beautiful look of near-pure gold with most of the practical benefits of an alloy.

This extra purity can be particularly evident with 18K yellow or rose gold, which tends to exhibit a warmer, more vibrant tone in 18K gold than in 14K gold.

The higher purity level of 18K gold also makes it less likely to trigger skin allergies than 14K or 10K gold. Although 18-karat gold still contains nickel and other alloying metals, they are only present in small amounts, making the risk of contact dermatitis or other allergic reactions very low.

Cons of 18-karat gold

Unfortunately, the biggest advantage of 18-karat gold—its purity—is also its biggest disadvantage. Because of its higher percentage of pure gold, 18-karat gold is significantly softer and easier to scratch or dent than 14-karat gold.

This means that if your future fiancée works with their hands or has an active lifestyle, an 18-karat gold ring may not be the best choice.

Another disadvantage of 18-karat gold is its price. As we briefly mentioned above, 18-karat gold costs significantly more than 14-karat gold, with most 18-karat gold engagement rings selling for 150% to 200% more than their 14-karat gold counterparts.

14K Gold or 18K Gold: Which type of gold should you buy?

14K gold and 18K gold are both excellent metal choices for an engagement ring, although each is suitable for a different type of person.

If your future fiancée is very active or works with their hands, a 14-karat gold engagement ring will be a better choice. Not only will it be more durable than an 18-karat gold ring, but it will also cost a little less while still looking absolutely beautiful. Joey King's engagement ring is in yellow or rose gold and although we don't know if it's 14K or 18K, it is simply magnificent.

As we mentioned above, 14K gold is used in about 90% of engagement rings sold for the following reasons: it is beautiful, affordable, and durable.

If you are not concerned about durability and want the purest form of gold while remaining practical for an engagement ring, 18-karat gold may be a better choice. However, be aware that this type of gold can scratch easily and often does, which means your future fiancé will need to be more careful.

Finally, if your future fiancé is allergic to nickel, 18-karat gold is a better choice than 14K because it is less likely to cause contact dermatitis.

FAQs about 14K and 18K gold

Is it better to buy 14K or 18K gold?
14K gold and 18K gold both make good purchases for engagement rings or gold jewelry. The choice depends on your budget and how much you want to spend on a higher-quality type of gold. If you are on a tighter budget, you can absolutely opt for 14-karat gold rather than 18-karat gold.

Is 18K gold worth more than 14K gold?
18-karat gold is significantly more expensive than 14-karat gold. This is an important factor to consider when buying an engagement ring or other gold jewelry, as you will often have the choice between 18K and 14K gold.

Is 14K or 18K gold better for daily wear?
For daily wear, 14K gold can be the better choice. 18-karat gold jewelry can also be worn every day, but it is a bit less durable and a bit more prone to scratching than 14-karat gold jewelry.

Does 18-karat gold last longer than 14-karat gold?
14K gold tends to be more durable than 18K gold, due to its higher content of metals other than gold. It is therefore more resistant to scratches and dents. However, in the long term, these metals can corrode or discolor, which is not the case with gold. In this sense, one could say that 18-karat gold lasts longer, due to its higher gold content.

Is 14K or 18K gold better?
18K gold is the higher-quality gold. It is purer, with 75% gold compared to 58.3%. 18-karat gold is therefore more beautiful and more valuable. But it is not always the better purchase. If you are looking for greater durability and have less money to spend, 14-karat gold may be the better choice.

What is the best type of gold for a ring?
14K or 18K gold is best for rings. They are more durable than higher-karat golds, while still maintaining a relatively high purity and the rich color of gold that characterizes them.

14K 18K 58,5 % d’or · plus dur · moins cher 75 % d’or · plus tendre · plus riche DEUX ÉQUILIBRES DIFFÉRENTS

14-karat gold: what the hallmark says exactly

A 14-karat gold piece of jewelry bears one of the markings 585 or 583 depending on the country of manufacture. The number indicates the fineness in thousandths: 585 means 585 grams of pure gold per 1,000 grams of alloy.

The difference between 583 and 585 comes from a historical rounding. It has no practical consequence: it is the same alloy, marked according to two conventions.

Marking Karats Pure gold Common usage
999 24K 99.9% Bullion, store of value
916 22K 91.6% Traditional Asian jewelry
750 18K 75% European high jewelry
585 / 583 14K 58.5% Global standard for wearable jewelry
417 10K 41.7% High-stress pieces, US market
375 9K 37.5% European entry-level

Where to look for the hallmark? Inside the band for a ring, on the clasp or a tag for a chain, on the post for an earring.

The total absence of markings on a piece sold as solid gold is a serious red flag.

What is in the remaining 41.5%

This is where everything happens: color, hardness, skin reaction. A yellow 14K gold and a white 14K gold have the exact same gold content, but very different properties.

Color Typical alloying metals Consequence
Yellow gold Balanced silver + copper, some zinc Warm hue, good overall compromise
White gold Palladium or nickel, silver, zinc Harder, often rhodium-plated on the surface
Rose gold Dominant copper The hardest of the three, copper tint
Green gold Dominant silver, no copper Rare, pale hue, very soft

The case of nickel

Historically used to whiten gold, it is the primary cause of contact allergy to jewelry. Contemporary jewelry largely prefers palladium, which is more expensive but neutral to the skin.

If you react to jewelry, the question is therefore not "14K or 18K" but "what white alloy". This is a point that is too rarely explained.

1-carat moissanite pavé-set solitaire engagement ring

On a pavé setting, the hardness of the alloy counts as much as its gold content: it protects the prongs.

Hardness: the figures behind the impression

We read everywhere that 14K is "stronger". This is true, and it is measured on the Vickers hardness scale, with significant differences.

Or 24KOr 18KOr 14KOr 10K DURETÉ RELATIVE — PLUS LA BARRE EST LONGUE, PLUS L’ALLIAGE RÉSISTE

What it means in daily life

  • An 18K ring worn every day will pick up micro-scratches faster than a 14K one.
  • The prongs of an 18K setting deform more easily upon impact.
  • A fine 18K chain stretches more than a 14K one under repeated tension.
  • A 14K clasp maintains its spring better over time.

Be careful not to exaggerate: 18K gold is not fragile. It simply requires a little more care for pieces exposed to impacts, i.e., primarily rings.

Price: how to calculate the real difference

Many think that 18K gold costs 28% more than 14K, since it contains 28% more gold. This is true for the material, false for the final price.

The breakdown of a jewelry price

Component Varies with karat?
Weight-based metal value Yes, proportionally
Manufacturing labor No
Set stones No
Setting No
Finishing and quality control No
Margin and distribution Partially

Consequence: on a highly intricate or heavily set piece, the 14K/18K price gap may be only a few percent. On a massive chain without stones, it approaches the theoretical difference in material cost.

The rule of thumb

The heavier and simpler a piece of jewelry is, the more the choice of karat impacts the bill. The lighter and more intricate it is, the less it counts.

For a heavy gold chain, the question of karat is therefore central. For a pavé ring, it is secondary.

Our article on heavy gold chains for men details the impact of weight on your budget.

Color: is the difference really visible?

10K14K18K24K pâleéquilibréchaudorangé rendu indicatif — la finition et le polissage modifient la perception

On yellow gold, the difference between 14K and 18K is perceptible side-by-side under good lighting. Alone, most people do not see it.

On rhodium-plated white gold, it is invisible: it is the surface rhodium that provides the color, not the alloy underneath.

On rose gold, the difference is clearest: 14K leans more towards copper, 18K towards a softer pink.

14K or 18K depending on the type of jewelry

Jewelry Recommendation Why
Ring worn daily 14K Constant impacts on hands
Wedding band 14K Constant wear, friction
Occasional ring 18K Less exposed, richer hue
Fine chain 14K Tensile strength
Heavy chain 14K or 10K High weight, budget is key
Pendant 18K possible Low mechanical stress
Earrings 18K possible Prolonged contact with skin
Bracelet 14K Area highly exposed to impact

A simple logic emerges: the more a piece takes a beating, the more 14K is required. The more gently it is worn, the more 18K is justified.

1 carat moissanite pavé halo engagement ring

On a halo, every small stone is held by microscopic prongs: alloy rigidity matters.

14K or 18K according to your lifestyle

You work with your hands

14K without hesitation, or even 10K for a wedding band. Manual labor, strength training, and gardening are the worst enemies of a soft setting.

You wear it occasionally, for special events

18K is a great choice. The hue is richer, and exposure to impact remains limited.

You have sensitive skin

Lean towards 18K, or 14K explicitly nickel-free. Always ask for the white alloy composition before buying.

You are looking for long-term value

18K, mechanically: more precious metal per gram. But remember that jewelry is rarely resold at its purchase price, regardless of the karat.

And 10K gold, should it be ruled out?

No, certainly not. 10K gold is the hardest of all jewelry golds and the most affordable. Its hue is simply paler, which suits certain styles very well.

It dominates the American market for massive pieces, precisely because it better withstands stress. In Europe, it remains less common due to commercial habits, not technical inferiority.

A detailed comparison can be found in our 10K vs 14K gold guide and our full comparison of 10K, 14K, 18K and 24K.

Maintenance: two golds, two levels of caution

  • 18K scratches more: avoid storing loosely, keep each piece in its own pouch.
  • 14K tarnishes a bit more: needs soapy cleaning more frequently.
  • White gold of both types requires periodic re-rhodium plating.
  • Chlorine attacks both, and more so the alloys rich in copper.
  • Neither likes ultrasonic cleaners when stones are set.

The complete method is detailed in our guide on how to clean your gold jewelry.

7 errors to avoid when buying

  1. Comparing two pieces without knowing their weight. Karat tells you nothing about the amount of gold.
  2. Believing 18K white gold is "whiter." It is the rhodium that determines the color.
  3. Choosing 18K for a wedding band for manual work. Regret comes quickly.
  4. Ignoring the alloy composition if you have reactive skin.
  5. Taking a price-per-gram as the price of the piece. The craftsmanship often weighs heavier.
  6. Buying without a visible hallmark. Solid gold is always hallmarked.
  7. Mixing 14K and 18K in the same set: the difference in hue eventually becomes visible.

Favorite products

Explore also: engagement rings, diamond rings and diamond jewelry for women.

Supplementary FAQ — 14K and 18K gold

What does the 585 hallmark mean?

It indicates 14-karat gold, or 585 parts pure gold per 1,000. The 583 marking designates the same alloy according to a different rounding convention.

Does 14-karat gold turn black?

The gold itself does not turn black, but the alloy metals can tarnish. Since 14K contains more of these than 18K, it requires slightly more frequent cleaning.

Can you see the difference between 14K and 18K with the naked eye?

Side by side on yellow or rose gold, yes, the 18K hue is warmer. On rhodium-plated white gold, the difference is invisible because the rhodium provides the color.

Why is the price difference not 28%?

Because labor, stones, and setting costs do not depend on the karat. The gap approaches the material cost on a heavy and simple piece, and shrinks significantly on a highly intricate one.

Which gold to choose when you have sensitive skin?

Opt for 18K gold, or 14K gold whose white alloy is palladium-based rather than nickel-based. Nickel is the number one cause of contact allergy to jewelry.

Is 10-karat gold "bad" gold?

No, it is the hardest of all jewelry golds and the most affordable. Its hue is simply paler, which is perfectly suited for massive pieces that are subject to high stress.

Conclusion: the right karat depends on the usage

There is no absolute winner between 14-karat gold and 18-karat gold. 14K buys durability and a contained budget; 18K buys purity and a richer hue.

Ask yourself three questions: will the piece be worn every day, is it subject to impact, does your skin react to jewelry? The answers will point you to the right karat.

➡️ Discover our engagement rings and diamond jewelry.

Read also

Frequent searches: 14-karat gold, 14k gold, 14k, 14k vs 18k gold, difference between 14 and 18 karat gold, 585 hallmark, 750 hallmark, 585 gold value, which gold to choose for ring, 18-karat gold price, 14-karat gold price per gram, 14k or 18k white gold, 14-karat gold allergy, best gold for wedding band, 10k 14k 18k gold difference.


The Emir ICE journal

Keep reading

All articles

Follow the workshop on Instagram @emirice24k

EMIR ICE

NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION

Subscribe to our newsletter to follow our latest news...

♦ Accès prioritaire aux nouvelles collections • Offres exclusives • Désabonnement à tout moment